I was talking to someone recently who believes that God does indeed exist (Yahweh), and that the bible is his book, but that god is exactly as he seems.
Contradictory
Capricious
Angry
Merciful (at times, to whomever he pleases)
Vengeful
Jealous
etc
One can argue that the New Testament did away with the seemingly wrathful deity of the OT, but Jesus one-ups that with the threat of eternal punishment.
I know that many atheists appear to be angry, and I don't believe that it is that we are MAD at god, which is what so many claim, but just angry about pouring our whole heart, mind and soul into something that we found out later to not be true. For believing wholeheartedly in something with little to no evidence. But maybe there are some out there that do think that there is a god and he is just not good.
What a horrific thought.
I guess I would have been closer to that thought in my Calvinstic days. What Calvinistic doctrine
did do for me was to take those horrible and contradictory passages and not shy away from them, but use them to prove the doctrine of election and all the other things that go with sovereign grace theology. The "love" part was only if he chose you, he wouldn't torture you forever like everyone else.
I guess what attracted me most about Calvinsim was that I could take the whole bible, and not have to explain unpleasent things away. One preacher I used to listen to all the time after giving a somewhat
sinners-in-the-hands-of-an-angry-god sermon said,
"That's the God you're dealing with."
And at the time I said "Amen!"
But could we really call this LOVE?
And then all the cognitive dissonance, not of textual contradictions, but of what love really means started.
I remember watching the movie and later reading the book
1984 as a teen and how profoundly it moved me at the time. Imagine living in a world where you were not safe even inside your own mind. Where you are told lies and given misinformation and you just have to keep on smiling and trying to convince yourself it is true, even if you don't really believe it, or even if it is horrible.
Killing everyone in a flood is not loving.
Killing the firstborn of Egypt is not loving.
Asking Abraham to kill his son to prove loyalty is not loving.
Eternal punishment after death is in no way loving.
There are kazillions of apologetic books and teachings and theories that try to tell us just the opposite.
I think this is where many of us unbelievers sound angry.
(
We've always been at war with Eastasia).
I asked this person why they still believed at all after explaining my disbelief and it came down to personal experiences. We all have them and it is impossible to tell someone theirs is not genuine and I had no desire to argue. Our own experiences are so very important to us.
For who among men knows the thoughts of a man except the spirit of the man ?
For me, it was my experience that there is no proof for this god above any other, and for that I'm glad.