If there's a new way,
I'll be the first in line.
But it better work this time.
Megadeth- Peace Sells
"You're a very all or nothing person," she said to me as we talked recently at her kitchen table on a sunny but very cold afternoon. The kids, hers and mine, were being very loud but having a very good time. It sure would have been nice if they could have gone outside to play. We met five years ago or so at our last church and though she left that particular church some time before we did, we have kept in touch. It had been a long time since we'd seen each other and at our previous gathering over six months earlier, I told her about my doubts (kind of).
![]() |
| Our summer cookout area |
On that sunny and very summery day at our house she asked,
"Well, do you believe in the death, burial, and resurrection?"
"Yes?"....(not really, but I'm not ready to admit it yet was going through my mind.)
Back to recently, she asked about where I was in all this. She knew, I think through mutual friends, but I'm sure she wanted to hear it from me.
"I just don't believe it anymore."
Not wanting to pry but wanting to talk, if I wanted, she brought the tissues as it became clear that I wasn't going to be able to talk about this without crying yet, maybe never. I certainly couldn't go through all the reasons and explain them all. Long story short was I just don't think it is the truth.
We talked a bit more about other things. She refrained from saying she'd pray for me or I was never saved or that I just wanted to sin or anything like that. But that is not really her style anyway. She knows in the little bit of time she's known me how much I put into this. And I know we'll remain friends, I hope so.
I've heard from others, too, that if I just wasn't so all or nothing in this thing, I could have a healthier spirituality, but I can't.
It's either true or it is not.
Recently I read a blog post where the author states that she cannot either. When speaking of certain passages referring to God's wrath she wrote:
It has been suggested that these verses pertaining to all of this wrath are fallible man’s attempt to understand God, but have in the process completely misunderstood His nature. I’m not sure I can buy into that view. Either these were prophets of God, or they weren’t. (emphasis mine)
Exactly. I know others can have the same set of facts and scriptures and can still believe.
I can't. I am a black-and-white-all-or-nothing person when it comes to this. I gave my entire heart, mind and soul. I'm not satisfied to try to reconcile the promises of God by saying he didn't really mean what he said. This post (although long) is a good read and addresses much of what I'm trying to say quite well.
That is why I studied and researched the bible and theology so vehemently over the years. Why does the bible promise us things that just don't fit in with reality? What am I missing? I found what to me was the missing piece in the very last place I looked and I can't "unsee" it now.















