We are Stardust
Why I couldn't be a liberal/progressive Christian
The Kingdom was not to come with observation, but was a state of mind, a oneness with God. I found that it was difficult to pin down what this whole thing (Christianity) was about anymore.
Especially what the whole Jesus thing was about.
If the kingdom of God was within us, what did Jesus have to do with that?
Several months before all this started, a friend had blogged that her husband had blogged about some atonement theory that I had never heard of. When looking into that I was surprised to find that Penal Substitution (which is what I learned pretty much from the start) was not one that was always believed and that, really, there had been several ideas to come out of theological minds (and scripture) as to why Jesus had to die.
Did God demand blood or did Jesus offer it?
Was Jesus's death a payment for sin or a ransom to Satan?
Was He a martyr or a victim?
To get us back to the Garden or to save us from Hell?
(One could pick any one of these ideas and run with it, but what was the TRUTH?)
I began to venture out into the sites of liberal/progressive Christians. As much as I enjoyed the non-judgmental love and the great social justice ideas something was off. For the most part progressives are for gay marriage rights and the ordination of women and many are even pro choice, but what did the bible say about these things?
Many would point to the red letters only. Okay, I get that idea, but if these same letters were in the same canon with all this other stuff, what was true and what was not? And even so, Jesus said that if one divorces, it constitutes adultery. ????? How many churches are still clinging onto that one? Even in a metaphorical sense, Jesus says a lot of things that many Christians ignore:
(I know this video is quite irreverent, forgive me)
It started to occur to me that just about all of us pick and chose what we think Jesus's words mean. I found many of the things he said so unsettling that I was thrilled when Pauline dispensationalism entered my life years before.
So in looking into these red letter words more closely and very seriously for the first time (if this was the only part of the bible we could really count on) something was becoming more and more clear.
The whole thing (including the red letters) was full of contradictions, or at least it seemed to me. At that I began to look into these contradictions objectively without running to apologists to comfort me. I also began to wander outside the boundaries of Christianity and explore what the other faiths had to say about spirituality.
Next Part
